New York state officials have reached a formal settlement with T-Mobile following an extensive investigation into the telecommunications giant’s compliance with the New York Affordable Broadband Act (ABA). The state alleged that T-Mobile violated the law by imposing restrictive data caps and aggressive speed throttling on home Internet plans specifically designed for low-income households. Under the terms of the settlement, T-Mobile has agreed to eliminate these data and speed limitations, expand the availability of the required affordable plans to underserved regions, and improve transparency regarding how customers can locate and enroll in these services.
The investigation, spearheaded by the office of Governor Kathy Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James, determined that T-Mobile’s implementation of its fixed wireless service for low-income New Yorkers fell significantly short of the statutory requirements mandated by the ABA. This legislation, which survived a rigorous four-year legal challenge from major industry trade groups, requires Internet Service Providers (ISPs) with at least 20,000 customers in the state to provide reliable, high-speed broadband to income-eligible residents at set, affordable price points.
The Scope of the Violation
The core of the dispute centered on T-Mobile’s home Internet plans marketed to low-income populations. According to the New York Attorney General’s findings, T-Mobile imposed a 50 GB-per-month data cap on these plans. Once a user exceeded this threshold, the company throttled their connection speeds from a functional 25 Mbps down to a sluggish 600 Kbps. State officials noted that in the modern digital age, where remote work, online education, and telehealth services are common, a typical household could exhaust that 50 GB allotment in as little as four days.
Furthermore, the investigation revealed that T-Mobile had restricted the availability of these affordable plans exclusively to areas with 5G coverage, effectively excluding residents in 4G-only areas who might otherwise be eligible for the service. To compound these barriers, the company was found to have utilized technical "noindex" tags on its website, which prevented search engines from indexing the pages dedicated to the Affordable Broadband Act plans. This design choice made it significantly more difficult for vulnerable New Yorkers to discover the existence of the discounted service, let alone enroll in it.

Chronology of the Affordable Broadband Act
The enforcement of the Affordable Broadband Act has been a protracted process marked by significant industry pushback.
- 2021: The New York state legislature passes the Affordable Broadband Act, mandating that ISPs offer high-speed home Internet to income-eligible households for $15 per month for 25 Mbps, or $20 per month for 200 Mbps.
- 2021–2024: Major broadband industry lobby groups, including CTIA—the wireless industry association representing companies like T-Mobile—sue the state of New York, arguing that the law is preempted by federal regulations.
- December 2024: The U.S. Supreme Court rejects the industry’s final appeal, clearing the way for the law to take full effect.
- January 2025: New York officially begins the active enforcement of the ABA, requiring ISPs to come into compliance.
- June 2025: The New York Department of Public Service alerts the Attorney General’s office to potential compliance failures within T-Mobile’s service offerings.
- November 2026: A formal settlement is reached, compelling T-Mobile to rectify its service restrictions and improve accessibility.
Technical and Regulatory Implications
The settlement forces a paradigm shift in how T-Mobile delivers its fixed wireless product within New York. Under the new agreement, T-Mobile must cease the practice of throttling speeds to 600 Kbps after a data cap. The company is required to make these affordable plans available at every address where it offers residential fixed wireless service, regardless of whether that service is delivered via 5G or 4G LTE technology.
The agreement does contain a narrow exception: if T-Mobile is objectively unable to provide a minimum download speed of 25 Mbps to a standard, full-price customer at a specific location, it is not required to provide that speed to an ABA-enrolled customer at that same location. However, this is intended to address legitimate technical limitations rather than serve as a loophole for discriminatory service provisioning.
From a regulatory standpoint, this settlement serves as a warning to other ISPs. The New York Attorney General’s office maintains the authority to pursue litigation if the terms of this Assurance of Discontinuance are not met. Potential penalties for future violations include restitution to affected consumers and civil penalties of up to $1,000 per violation.
Broader Industry Landscape
The T-Mobile settlement arrives at a time of heightened tension between state-level consumer protection efforts and federal deregulatory trends. The incoming Trump administration has signaled a potential desire to preempt state-level broadband regulations, particularly those concerning price controls or net neutrality, especially for ISPs receiving federal funding via the $42 billion Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program.

California and New York remain at the forefront of the resistance to these federal preemption attempts, arguing that states possess the sovereign authority to protect their citizens from predatory pricing and deceptive service practices. The conflict reflects a larger ideological divide over whether broadband is a utility that should be subject to state-level oversight or a market-driven service that should remain largely exempt from local regulation.
T-Mobile’s Response and Track Record
In its official statement, T-Mobile did not admit to any wrongdoing, a standard clause in many corporate settlements. "We have a long history of helping customers in New York stay connected through low-cost broadband, and we’re updating our plan to meet the state’s requirements while maintaining the same low price," the company stated. They further committed to providing greater clarity on their website and ensuring broader availability.
This settlement is not the first time T-Mobile has faced scrutiny from the New York Attorney General. Just last month, the company was involved in a separate settlement regarding its "Price Guarantee" plans. A state investigation found that between 2017 and 2019, T-Mobile marketed plans with a lifetime price lock, only to raise the rates by $5 per line in 2024. That agreement resulted in approximately $38 million in estimated value for consumers in the form of reimbursement options and extended price protections, alongside a fine paid to the state.
Conclusion: The Road Ahead
The resolution of the T-Mobile case highlights the critical importance of oversight in the telecommunications sector. By successfully challenging a major national carrier, New York has demonstrated that state-level legislation can be a potent tool in bridging the digital divide. For the thousands of New Yorkers who qualify for the Affordable Broadband Act, the settlement represents a meaningful victory for digital equity.
However, the ease with which these violations persisted for nearly two years after the law’s passage suggests that compliance monitoring remains a challenge. As the state moves forward, the focus will likely shift from initial enforcement to long-term auditing of ISP performance. The ultimate success of the Affordable Broadband Act will depend not only on the existence of these low-cost plans but on the willingness of companies to provide quality, unthrottled service to the residents who need it most. As the telecommunications industry continues to evolve, the tension between corporate profitability and public service obligations will likely remain a central theme in state and federal policy discussions for years to come.



